Questions - Fair Work in your sector - Opportunities
1. What is the main sector you work in or represent?
Please select your main sector
Please select one item
Radio button:
Unticked
Accommodation and food service activities
Radio button:
Unticked
Activities of extraterritorial organisations and bodies
Radio button:
Unticked
Activities of households as employers; undifferentiated goods and services-producing activities of households for own use
Radio button:
Unticked
Administrative and support service activities
Radio button:
Unticked
Agriculture, forestry and fishing
Radio button:
Unticked
Arts, entertainment and recreation
Radio button:
Unticked
Construction
Radio button:
Unticked
Education
Radio button:
Unticked
Electricity, gas, steam and air conditioning supply
Radio button:
Unticked
Financial and insurance activities
Radio button:
Unticked
Human health and social work activities
Radio button:
Unticked
Information and communication
Radio button:
Unticked
Manufacturing
Radio button:
Unticked
Mining and quarrying
Radio button:
Unticked
Other service activities
Radio button:
Ticked
Professional, scientific and technical activities
Radio button:
Unticked
Public administration and defence; compulsory social security
Radio button:
Unticked
Real estate activities
Radio button:
Unticked
Transport and storage
Radio button:
Unticked
Water supply; sewerage, waste management and remediation activities
Radio button:
Unticked
Wholesale and retail trade; repair of motor vehicles and motor cycles
2. What are the main opportunities for adopting fair work practices in your sector?
Please explain your answer
Flexible/reduced hours and remote working.
3. Please explain how you think these opportunities can be maximised in your sector?
Please explain your answer
There no technical blockers, it only needs an agreement with the employer.
Questions - Fair Work in your sector - Challenges
4. What are the main challenges to adopting fair work practices in your sector?
Please write your answer here
One significant challenge is employment agencies. Generally, the focus is not on the interests or needs of the employee, or sending the most suitable candidate to a company, but the immediate financial benefits to the agency of getting a candidate into a job that provides a good return.
In terms of employers, as long as they are honest and upfront about their working practices then potential employees can decide whether or not that is somewhere they belong.
In terms of employers, as long as they are honest and upfront about their working practices then potential employees can decide whether or not that is somewhere they belong.
5. Please explain how you think these challenges might be overcome, including your ideas on any specific interventions and support needed in your sector?
Please write your answer here
An examination of how employment agencies conduct themselves e.g. the casual dishonesty and questionable use of data.
Questions - Fair Work in the current economic context
6. What do you believe are the barriers to delivering Fair Work given the current economic challenges in Scotland?
Please write your answer here
The economic challenges result from the actions of various governments including the Scottish Government. The Scottish Government is therefore one of the barriers.
Furthermore, as long as the views of transgender, BLM and woke campaigners are considered sacrosanct, there can never be any "fair" work.
Furthermore, as long as the views of transgender, BLM and woke campaigners are considered sacrosanct, there can never be any "fair" work.
7. What do you believe are the opportunities for delivering Fair Work in the current economic climate in Scotland?
Please write your answer here
None - the government and media have been pushing fear for circa 2 years. Add to that the divisive woke campaigns fracturing society, is this really the best time to be discussing "Fair Work" while some may be afraid of cancellation for having any alternate opinion?
Questions - Further actions to deliver Fair Work
8. Please set out any further actions you think the Scottish Government should take to deliver fair work for everyone. This may include, for example, any further support you think is needed.
Please set out below any further actions actions you think are needed to deliver fair work for everyone, including who you think should take this action. This may include, for example, strengthening of current actions or any further support you think is needed.
Conceptually, Fair Work seems reasonable but reality is a bit different. Some people don't want to contribute in the workplace. Some people do not have the appropriate skills and no amount of training changes that, they may be better suited to a position elsewhere. Fair Work risks enabling their permanency in an ill-suited role. The burden moves to those who do contribute and who do have the skills. This may cause them to leave, taking their work-ethic and skillset elsewhere.
Fair Work might sink businesses that cannot afford to carry staff who aren't best suited to the role for which they were hired. It could create resentment among hard-working staff who are considered equal to under-performing colleagues because that is what Fair Work demands. It can bring the work of employees down to the level of the most incapable rather than inspiring ingenuity and creativity. Why work hard to be considered equal to someone who isn't?
With this in mind, the Scottish Government should do nothing. The workplace may not be ideal but the government is not capable of competently managing society to this level. Who says we want them to? At this point in time, it looks like another step towards a totalitarian state.
Fair Work might sink businesses that cannot afford to carry staff who aren't best suited to the role for which they were hired. It could create resentment among hard-working staff who are considered equal to under-performing colleagues because that is what Fair Work demands. It can bring the work of employees down to the level of the most incapable rather than inspiring ingenuity and creativity. Why work hard to be considered equal to someone who isn't?
With this in mind, the Scottish Government should do nothing. The workplace may not be ideal but the government is not capable of competently managing society to this level. Who says we want them to? At this point in time, it looks like another step towards a totalitarian state.
9. Please set out any other actions you think are required to deliver Fair Work for everyone, including who should take this action.
Please set out below any other actions you think are required to deliver Fair Work for everyone, including who should take this action
Employees need to take action for themselves to make changes happen.
Questions - Fair Work and employment powers
10. If Scotland had full control over employment law, which issues would you like to see addressed as a priority in order to deliver fairer work in Scotland?
Please write your answer here
If the current regime had full control over employment law, I think they would already have decided on a course of action given they are aligned with UN 2030.
Questions - further ideas
11. What is the most important thing that you or your organisation can do to help Scotland become a Fair Work Nation?
Please write your answer here
Be supportive of employees with recognition that some people might not be suited to that workplace and may need some assistance to make way for a replacement that will contribute to the success of the organisation.
About you
15. Are you responding as an individual or an organisation?
Please select one item
(Required)
Radio button:
Ticked
Individual
Radio button:
Unticked
Organisation